Bhagavad gita – Mahabharata is real or a myth?

Did Mahabharata truly occur? Is Mahabharata true? Mahabharata is constantly connected with Hinduism and immensity affects Hindus and their social customs. Numerous individuals in India consider Mahabharata as genuine history and they quote occasions from the epic as obvious records of history. In this manner it has turned into a theme of discussion, if the Mahabharata portrays the genuine history. We are endeavoring to discover answers to two inquiries here – Did Mahabharata truly occur? Is Mahabharata real?

On the off chance that you ever endeavor to discover the appropriate response by making inquiries or surfing the web, you will in all probability get one side of the feeling. Individuals of confidence would state that it is surely genuine and there not a smidgen of uncertainty that it is in reality our Indian history. Besides they guarantee they have genuine confirmation of Mahabharata and its accuracy.

Then again, individuals of academic network and cynics out-appropriately dismiss it as history call it folklore. They anyway don’t answer the inquiry about for what reason does it have such a significant effect on Hindu Society.So where does reality lie? Is Mahabharata a fantasy or reality?

Mahabharata isn’t just an epic of confidence for Hindus, as it is broadly perceived. Different religions like Sikhism, Jainism and Buddhism likewise have different relationship with Mahabharata and is a necessary piece of these religions and culture.

More or less, anything that has some starting point in India likewise has some relationship with Mahabharata. This in itself is a solid contention that piece of the epic must to consistent with have this sort of effect on aggregate memory of such various social orders.

Artist depiction of Krishna narrating Bhagvat Geeta to Arjun

Bhagvat Geeta that is one amongst the foremost well-known and necessary holy books in Hinduism could be a a part of Mahabharatum.

Bhagvat Geeta is claimed to be a documented narrative of god Krishna to Arjun to satisfy his obligation and fight within the war of Kurukshetra. If Mahabharatum is n’t real then who wrote Geeta and what was the purpose?

We have tried to answer a number of the queries by 1st analyzing what are the obtainable evidences from that it is inferred that Mahabharatum is real. i have to tell you these are terribly sturdy facts and not mere religion based mostly arguments.

Let us currently examine them. allow us to observe the ‘Scientific proof of Mahabharata’

Facts that support Mahabharatum happened for real

DPS Bali country Kuta. sculpture of ArjunaKrishna and Bima, introductory scene of Bhagavad religious writing

1. Records of India dynasties and real historical lineage

It is mentioned in Aadiparva, the book of the startthat is that the1st of eighteen books of the Mahabharatum, chapter sixty two concerning the records of the Bharat-Dynasty (interestingly the name of India ‘Bharat’ has the origin from it), and its lineage are recorded .More than fifty kings and their dynasties ranging from king Manu are conferred very well. A fictional tale as we all know would hardly use 5-6 of them.

Bharat childhood image creator depiction

2. it’s written as Itihas (History)

In Mahabharat it’s clearly written that it’s associate degree “Itihas’ (Sanskrit word for History). The words “Puraan” and “Itihas” were specifically coined by the traditional folks to reason the “ancient” and “recent” events. each the words denote history that has occurred at totally different times. If the intention of the author was to jot down a verse form or a piece of fiction, he would have expressed it to be a “Mahakavya” (epic) or “Katha” (story) that was a convention at that point.

Cenotaph of Sage Vyas ,wrote Mahabharatum

3. Description of contemporary world in past

Read the outline of Kaliyuga as mentioned in Mahabharatumno matter Krishna fore told concerning future civilization in Kalyug (Modern Times) came true, howeverplease note that these weren’t prophecies however are the a part of Geeta. And bear in mind – this was written thousands of years ago! Fiction? Unlikely as a result of there are method too several corroborations and tallying circumstances for it to be fiction.

Depiction of God Krishna

4. archeological proof of the lost town of Dwarka

Marine archaeology where as exploring the traditional submerged town of Dwaraka in Gujarat, uncovered any evidences in support of statements within the religious text scriptures. a whole submerged town at Dwaraka, the traditional port town of Lord Krishna with its large fort walls, piers, warfs and barrier has been found within the ocean as delineated within the Mahabharat and different Veda.

Dwarka Submerged town

5. Real places mentioned in Mahabharat and archeological proof

Hastinapur-The capital of Mahabharat kingdom

More than thiry sites in North India have yielded archeological proof and are known as ancient cities delineated within the Mahabharat. Copper utensils, iron, seals, gold & silver ornaments, terracotta discs and painted gray ware pottery have all been found in these sites. Scientific qualitative analysis of those artifacts corresponds to the non-Aryan-invasion model of Indian antiquity.

All places mentioned in Mahabharatum are real places, all are known and still exist with the identical name. as an example, Hastinapur is in UP with multiple proof of Mahabharatum in Hastinapur. Indraprastha is that the gift day metropolis. Dwarka is found in Gujarat coast. Kurukshetra wherever the war truly happened is in gift day Haryana terribly with reference tometropolis.

Interestingly this is often not restricted to solely India. The Kekaya kingdom is found in today’s Asian country, Madra Kingdom is found in today’s Asian country. Gandhara Kingdom is found in today’s Islamic State of Afghanistan. Kambojas Kingdom is found in today’s Islamic Republic of Iran. Parama Kamboja Kingdom is found in today’s Tajikistan.

Recently researchers have found town of Dwarka below the ocean within the a fore mentioned place. Mahabharat cities are n’ t restricted to gift day India as a result of Mahabharat referred Indian landmass as India.

6. Progression from Ramayana

Mahabharata could be a continuation from Ramayana

Mahabharata could be a continuation of the dynasties from Ramayana and it’s a well-established coherence within the chain of events. Even the relations between totally different kings and their dynasties in each the good “epics” match with one another.

If each were mere “epics” written by 2 entirely totally different persons, at 2 totally different purpose in times, why would everything match to even minute details? Mahabharatum happens thousand of years when Ramayanawhat’s the requirement for the author of the Mahabharat borrow the identical concepts and characters as those of the author of Ramayana?

7. Astronomical references

Mahabharata could be a continuation from Ramayana

The Udyoga Parva of Mahabharatum narrates that, simply before the War, Lord Krishna visited Hastinapur within the month of Kartika on the day once moon was at the asterism Revati.

On His thanks to Hastinapur, Krishna took rest for each day at an area known as Brikasthala, and on it day the moon was at the asterism Bharani. The day on that Duryodhana turned down all the efforts of Krishna and created the war inevitable, the moon was resting at the asterism Pushya.

8. story of Aryan invasion theory

European students brought the peregrine Aryan tribes, into India when 1500 B.C.however may these Aryans produce Sanskrit language, gain such a lot information and write of these texts before 700 BC? nice Indian thinkers together with Lokmanya Tilak, Sri Arbindo, and Dyanand Hindu deity rejected the ecu theory.

9. Historical references that are true

Maurya, Gupta and Indo-Greek dynasties, are recorded in our Purana. These dynasties are accepted solely as a result of they’re additionally recorded by Greek historians. What concerning the dynasties that existed before the Greek historians?

10. renowned nuclear physicist quote

Oppenheimer nice scientist mentions Hindu Epic

The design erof contemporary fission bomb World Health Organization was to blame of the Manhattan project was asked by a student when the Manhattan explosion, “How does one feel when having exploded the primary fission bomb on earth”. Oppenheimer’s reply for the question was, “not 1st fission bombhowever 1st fission bomb in moderntimes”. He powerfully believed that nukes were utilized in ancient India.

As he witnessed the primary detonation of a weapon of mass destruction on Gregorian calendar month sixteen, 1945, a chunk of Hindu scripture ran through the mind of Henry Martyn Robert Oppenheimer: “Now i’m become Death, the destroyer of worlds”. It is, perhaps, the foremost well-known line from the Bhagavad-Gita, however additionally the foremost misunderstood.

11. Flying vehicles and nuclear war

Brahmastra is compared with modernnuclear weapons

The Indian Epics, particularly the Mahabharatdevelop the thread of the story of devastation and destruction. Sanskrit students couldn’t perceive what was being delineated within the Epics till the dropping of the primary atomic bombs on Japan happened. the consequences of radiation poisoning additionall y became clear.

Now these details are supplied with details in Mahabharatum. A details provided in Mahabharatum is roughly translated in English below:

Flying a swift and powerful Vimana (Aircraft) hurled one projectile Charged with all the facility of the Universe. associate degree incandescent column of smoke associate degreed flame as bright as 10 thousand Suns rose altogether its was an unknown weapon, associate degree iron thunderbolt, a big traveler of death, that reduced to ashes.

The Entire race of the Vrishnis and thr Andhakas….the corpses were thus burned on be unidentifiable. Their hair and nails fell out, pottery skint while not apparent cause and also the birds turned white. when some hours all foodstuffs were infected. to flee from this fire place, the troopers threw themselves in streams to scrub themselves and their instrumentality.

12. Real places with evidences that correlates with Mahabharatum

One of the nice examples could be a place, some kilometers from Gwalior, Morena (M.P.), India, wherever mother of Pandavas the heroes of Mahabharatum, Kunti invoked the Mantra given by Maharishi Durvasa and summoned Surya Bhagwan (Sun God) who appeared on a seven horsed chariot.

The dazzling heat of the chariot and also the horses thawed the rock, departure imprints on the rock. an image showing the identical.

Chariot and also the horses melting the rock

13. The enormity of details provided

Mahabharata has huge details over what ancient folks will manage

The Mahabharat is that the longest familiar {epic verse form|heroic poem|epic|epos|poem|verse form} and has been delineated as “the longest poem ever written”. Its longest version consists of over one hundred thousand shloka or over two hundred,thousand individual verse lines (each shloka could be a couplet), and long prose passages. About 1.8 million words in total, the Mahabharatum is roughly 10 times the length of the Iliadand also the Odyssey combined. (Source: Wikipedia)

In today’s world of smart phone and computers it’s going to appear straight forward to take care of coherence with an outsized quantity of informationcontemplate this in pastwherever there was no Ctrl+F to look through the big documents, maintain consistency and infer stories and cite references.

14. Physics in Mahabharatum

God Krishna showing his divine appearance-Did Mahabharat extremely happen

Whether it’s time travel, quantum physics or gravity all realize some mention in Mahabharata!

One of the terribly1st time travel stories recorded in history seems within the Mahabharatum. The story follows a king, his girl, and their seek for an ideal suer.

Revati was the solegirl of King Kakudmi, a strong monarch dominated Kusasthali, a prosperous and advanced kingdom below the ocean. Thinking nobody may to Brahmaloka, the house of Brahma, to raise the god’s recommendation concerning finding an acceptable husband for her.

Brahma was taking note of a performing arts after they arrived, then they waited with patience till the performance was finished. Finally, King Kakudmi humbly bowed and created his request:

“O Brahmâ! To whom shall I engage this daughter? i’ve got come back to you to raise on this time i’ve got looked fo rseveral princes and seen additionally a decent severalof them and none of them is to my feeling then my mind isn’t at rest.”

Brahma laughed at the foolishness of the King.

“O King! The princes that you simply thought would become the bridegroom of your girl, all died; their sons and grandsons and their friends even have all died.”

Time, as God Brahma goes on to elucidate, runs otherwise on totally different planes of existence. through out the time they’d waited in Brahmaloka to work out him, twenty seven chatur-yugas, had passed on Earth.

Everything that Kakudmi had and owned , his friends and family, his sons and woman, his armies and treasures, had non existent with the time that had passed.

The King and his girl were overcome with feeling and grief for everything they’d lost, however Brahma comfortable them, and counseled a worthy husband presently on earth: Ramathe dual brother of Krishna.

I know this is often as shut because it gets to elucidate the relative nature of your time or time jaun build it easy.

15. emission

Radioactivity finds an analogous mention in Mahabharatum

There are several claims of emission like in Jodhpur that is a minimum of 710 metric linear unit distant from the war of Kurukshetra. emission has been quoted collectively of the scientific argument presenting proof at totally different places in India together with big unexplained crater close tourban center.

Now these are terribl ysturdy arguments for Mahabharatum to be a true history. we have a tendency to examined every of the points and also the facts are conferred below

Facts that don’t support Mahabharatum happened for real

1. the big scale of destruction isn’tpotential

Mahabharata war destruction, inventive depiction

Four million dead throughout the war of Kurukshetra is documented in Mahabharatumwhereas scientific studies estimate the planet population to be around one hundred fifteen million in a thousandB.C.. If Mahabharatum must be valid as history it’s to own occurred before 4000 B.C.bear in mind we’ve sensible historical records from 5000 B.C. onward. the planet population estimate at that point is concerning seven to twenty-eight million within the whole world.

In addition, the actual fact that solely twelve folks survived the war. Out of four million solely eighteen folks living is in itself a miracle, augment that the actual fact that the righteous (Pandavas) were all living and rest four were the Kauravas or the not thus righteous opponent.

Strength of the armies mentioned in Mahabharat is found below

Pandava (the righteous brothers) Kauravas (the opponent)

7 Akshauhinis
153,090 chariots and chariot-riders
153,090 elephants and elephant-riders
459,270 horses and horse-riders
765,450 army unit
(total 1,530,900 soldiers)

11 Akshauhinis
240,570 chariots and chariot-riders
240,570 elephants and elephant-riders
721,710 horses and horse-riders
1,202,850 army unit
(total 2,405,700 soldiers)

Akshauhinis delineated within theMahabharat as a battle formation consisting of twenty one,870 chariots (Sanskrit ratha); twenty one,870 elephants; sixty five,610 horses and 109,350 army unit as per the Mahabharat

2. Astronomical references are cyclic in nature

Have you detected concerning the quantity of years it’ll want see similar eclipsehowever do they estimate that?

It is as a result of astronomical information is cyclic in nature and repeats itself each thousands if not many years, and below are the predictions for the date of Mahabharatum

P. V. Vartak calculates a date of sixteen October  5561 BCE mistreatment planetary positions.

P. V. porous states a date of thirteen Nov  3143 BCE mistreatment planetary positions and calendar systems.

Aihole inscriptions offer the date of Kurukshetra war around 3102 BCE.

K. Sadananda, supported translation work, states that the Kurukshetra War started on twenty two Nov  3067 BCE.

B. N. Achar used planetarium computer code to argue that the Mahabharatum War materialized in 3067 BCE.

S. Balakrishna terminated a date of 2559 BCE mistreatment consecutive satellite eclipses.

R. N. Iyengar terminated a date of 1478 BCE mistreatment double eclipses and Saturn+Jupiter conjunctions.

P. R. Sarkar estimates a date of 1298 BCE for the war of Kurukshetra.

V. S. Dubey claims that the war happened close to 950 BCE

If one event has such a lot of totally different predictions for date with a spread that exceeds a spread of 4500 years. One factor will so before mentioned concerning the event. you probably did not have sensible references for the date! Astronomical qualitative analysis premise is definitely dominated out.

3. Aryan theory is n’td ominated out by historians.

Purana themselves have elaborate details concerning Aryan ‘immigration’ which might be the correct word to use. This theory has not be dominated out by scholarly person and has enough archeological proof to support it.

4. Ancient Nuclear war theory is marginal

Ancient atomic explosion Theory

Before i purchase into the main points we have a tendency to should perceive why folks keep referencing that associate degree ancient fission bomb was so utilized in Mahabharatum, (including our friends from Ancient Aliens series) within thetype of a weapon known as Bramhastra’ the precise translated version of the text is given below

Vaishampayana said: “When the ordinal year (after the battle) was reached, the delighter of the Kurus, Yudhishthira, beheld several uncommon portents. Winds, dry and powerful, and showering gravels, blew from each facet.

Birds began to wheel, creating circles from right to left. the good rivers ran in opposite directions. The horizon on each face tperceived to be invariably coated with fog. Meteors, showering (blazing) coals, fell on the planet from the sky.

A single projectile charged with all the facility within the Universe… associate degree incandescent column of smoke and flame as bright as ten,thousand suns, rose altogether its splendor… it absolutely was associate degree unknown weapon, associate degree iron thunderbolt, a big traveler of death that reduced to ashes a whole race.

The corpses were thus burned on be un identifiable. Their hair and nails fell out, pottery skint with none apparent cause, and also the birds turned white.

After some hours, all foodstuffs were infected. to flee from this fireplace, the troopers threw themselves into the stream.

The Sun’s disc, O king, perceived to be invariablycoated with dirt. At its rise, the good celebrity of day was sheared of splendour and perceived to be crossed by headless trunks (of human beings). Fierce circles of sunshine were seen each day around each the Sun and also the Moon. These circles showed 3 hues…

There appears to be associate degree eerie respect to the fission bomb explosion and emission. Right? howeverthere’s nothing remotely like this story in any archeologicalpublications.

Archaeological infoconcerning the excavations of Mohenjo-Daro, Harappa, and different Indus vale sites is wide obtainable on-line and in print, and there’s merely no such factor as hot skeletons or skeletons in massive numbers or holding hands or sprawling in any method that the archaeologists saw reason to print.

Further more, the overwhelming majority of hot isotopes made during a nuclear blast have extraordinarily short 0.5 lives measured in seconds, hours, or days, and are reduced to safe levels terribly quickly.

Those that causethe best threat to human health are Cesium-137 and Strontium-90, that have 0.5 lives of thirty and twenty eight years, then even these would are reduced to well below the natural background levels thousands of years past.

Other long-lasting isotopes are made by nuclear explosions, however at a lot of lower amounts.

Note that despite the atomic destruction of metropolis and Nagasaki, no harmful radiation persists these days in either townplace along all the radiation informationand that we understand for a reality, with little doubt, that any claims of contemporary radiation in India proving a prehistoric nuclear war are false. thus we’ve sensible reason to treat the complete story with nice skepticism.

So however concerning this big unexplained crater close to Bombay? Lonar Crater — that is a few 775 kilometers southeast of Jodhpur, even farther away — is so a true crater. Rim to rim it measures concerning 1.8 km. it’s blasted out of thick layers of volcanic volcanic rock, deposited over the table land sixty six million years past. If the crater was so modern by a nuclear blast 8-12,000 years pastqualitative analysis techniques ought to build this straight forward to see.

For a protracted time, the accepted age of Lonar Crater was fifty two,thousand years; so much too recent to own been a part of this alleged nuclear war. This had been determined by thermo- luminescence qualitative analysisthat tells United States of America once the sample was last liquifiedhowever newer measurements, mistreatment argon-argon radiometric qualitative analysis instead, found older dates of 570,000 years and 656,000 years, with non-overlapping margins of error.

5. The submerged a part of Dwarka could be a post-Mauryan website

Remains of the underwater town of Dwarka picture

The comparative study of close sites indicates that the date of the structures of Dwarka could also be between amount|period|historic period|time period|period of time|period} and late medieval period. The paper reviews the sooner hypothesis concerning the identification and qualitative analysis of those structures in light weight of recent evidences from the recent underwater explorations.

It is terribly tough to mention the findings are from ancient age and don’t meet the factors as per Lord Krishna’s Dwarka narration and as per Purana and different ancient texts.

According to ancient literature, Lord Krishna based the Heavenly City of Dwarka, thatafter got submerged below ocean. Marine archeological explorations off Dwarka have dropped at light weight an outsized variety of stone structures, that are curving, rectangular and sq. in form in water depth starting from entomb zone to six m.

This shows that these sites were owner-occupied around this pointand also the nature of the remains suggests that the those who lived here shared a pastoral and agricultural living.

There is another kind of proof from Hastinapura: The Matsya and Hindu deity Puranas state that in the reign of king Nichakshu (fifth king within the Puranas. there’s a powerful native tradition that the Purana Qila in national capital marks the place wherever Indraprastha, the capital of the Pandavas, once stood.

Purana Quila might be the recent Indraprastha?

Shams Siraj Afif’s Tarikh-i-Firuz Shahi (14th century) states that Indraprastha was the headquarters of a Pargana (district).

fourteenth century stone inscription found in Naraina village in west metropolis additionally mentions Indraprastha.

The sixteenth century Ain-i-Akbari of Abul Fazl states that Humayun’s fort was designed at the place wherever Indraprastha, capital of the Pandavas, was situated way back.

In fact, untilthe tip of the nineteenth century, there was a village known as Indarpat within the fort walls.

Excavations dole out at the Purana Qila between 1954 and 1971 discovered many archeological levels starting from the fourth century BCE to the nineteenth century Ce.

The discovery of some stray items of PGW indicated the chance that associate degree older settlement was situated somewhere close. However, there’s no method of knowing needless to say whether or not this settlement had any reference to the Mahabharatum.

normity of the main points provided, long chain of lineage and physics

I must say that I couldn’t realize any proof which will give you with answer on however it absolutely was done. All we are able to say is that, it’s a superb epic with unprecedented ability and literary skills.

But we’ve a precedence wherever we have a tendency to didn’t understand how pyramids of Egypt were designed and it looked quite not possible for ancient folks to owncreated a structure of that proportion. currently we have a tendency tototally understand however ingenious our ancestors were and the way they designed them!

So at some point we have a tendency tomay additionally realize the solution to higher than queries.

So is Mahabharatum reality or fiction, Did Mahabharatum extremely happen?

We are attempting to verify the reality of the narrative here, not the setting itself. The thanks to verify a narrative are going to be to:

1. take away any licencetropeand spiritualreligion here.

2. ask for credible freelance sources that document the narrative with proof

3. realize archeological proof, artifacts and documentation which will be clearly copied back to the events of the narrative

We don’t have terribly sturdy proof for Mahabharatum as of these days on the given parameters. Our proof obtainable until date establishes.

It is associate degree iron age narrative

It was set {in a|during a|in associate degree exceedingly|in a very} universe that has no touching on scientific reality as we all know it – magic and demigods were an integral a part of the narrative with numerous supernatural (believed to be at present) powers and events.

The authors, redactors, and also the re-tellers of the epics could have modified the initial story, clearly demonstrating that they were alert to the fictional nature of thosestories; ask religious belief and Buddhist text that have competitive narratives.

The usual things provided as proof have largely been falsified

The Indus valley civilization was strictly Bronze Age and had nothing to try and do with the epics

The Gulf of Khambhat has been formally discharged by the government. of India, and their funding revoked and analysis erased

The submerged a part of Dwarka was a post-Mauryan website

In fact all geographical locations related to the epics are strictly post-Buddha and for the most part Sanskrit literature

So is Mahabharatum real, did Mahabharatum extremely happen as we all know today? we’ve conferred positive evidences that points to the actual fact that it’s a piece of fiction impressed by real incidents and may be real folksbut the narrative is filled with fantasies with no proof to substantiate the facts and so not “real”.

As it is usually a fore mentioned “Extraordinary claims need extraordinary evidence”

Without a shred of doubt Mahabharatum is that the greatest epic written however the complete narrative can not be afore mentioned to be real, supported this evidences and facts obtainable.

Visit to discover Indian blogs

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *